Main Level Flooring Dilemma: Hardwood or Luxury Vinyl Planks?

When it comes to selecting the ideal flooring for your main level, the choice between hardwood and luxury vinyl planks (LVP/LVT) can be challenging. Both options offer distinct advantages and potential drawbacks, influencing factors such as aesthetics, durability, maintenance, and cost. 

Whether you’re drawn to the timeless elegance of hardwood or the versatile and resilient nature of luxury vinyl planks, making an informed decision is crucial. In this article, we will delve into the features, benefits, and considerations of both hardwood floors and luxury vinyl planks to help you determine which flooring solution best suits your home’s main level.

Table of Contents

samples of hardwood floors and luxury vinyl

The Case for Hardwood Flooring

Hardwood flooring is a top choice for main levels due to its timeless beauty, durability, and potential to increase home value. It provides a classic look that can be refinished multiple times, ensuring longevity.

The Benefits of Hardwood Floors

Hardwood floors offer several significant advantages for your main level:

  • Timeless Beauty: Hardwood provides a classic, elegant appearance that enhances any home decor. Its natural grain and rich tones create a warm, inviting atmosphere.
  • Durability: With proper care, hardwood can last for decades. It can withstand high foot traffic and daily wear and tear.
  • Home Value: According to the National Association of Realtors, hardwood floors can increase the resale value of your home. Potential buyers often view hardwood as a premium feature.
  • Refinishing Potential: Hardwood floors can be sanded and refinished multiple times, allowing you to restore their original beauty or change their color to match new decor trends.
Close up view hardwood floor

Additional Considerations for Hardwood

While hardwood offers many benefits, it’s important to consider the following:

  • Maintenance: Hardwood requires regular upkeep, including sweeping and occasional refinishing, to maintain its appearance and prevent damage.
  • Cost: Hardwood floors tend to be more expensive upfront compared to other flooring options. However, their longevity and ability to be refinished can offset the initial investment over time.
  • Susceptibility to Moisture: Hardwood can be vulnerable to moisture and humidity, which can cause warping or damage. It’s essential to control indoor humidity levels and clean up spills promptly.
another close up view of hardwood floor

The Case for Luxury Vinyl Planks

Luxury vinyl planks (LVP) offer water resistance, durability, and affordability, making them an excellent choice for main levels. They are easy to maintain and come in a variety of styles. However, they may not add as much resale value as hardwood and have some environmental concerns.

Benefits of Luxury Vinyl Planks

Luxury vinyl planks (LVP) offer several advantages for your main level:

  • Water Resistance: LVP is highly resistant to moisture and spills, making it an ideal choice for areas prone to humidity and occasional water exposure.
  • Durability: LVP is designed to withstand heavy foot traffic, scratches, and dents. Its robust construction ensures longevity even in busy households.
  • Affordability: Compared to hardwood, LVP is more budget-friendly both in terms of material cost and installation. This makes it an attractive option for cost-conscious homeowners.
  • Variety of Styles: LVP comes in a wide range of designs and colors, many of which mimic the look of natural wood or stone. This allows for great flexibility in achieving the desired aesthetic.
  • Comfort: LVP has a softer underfoot feel compared to hardwood, providing a more comfortable walking surface. Some LVP options also include a cushioned backing for added comfort.
  • Easy Maintenance: Maintaining LVP is simple, requiring only regular sweeping and mopping with standard household cleaners. It does not require refinishing like hardwood.
samples of different colours of luxury vinyl floors

Potential Drawbacks of Luxury Vinyl Planks

While LVP has many benefits, there are also some potential drawbacks to consider:

  • Less Authentic Appearance: Although LVP can closely mimic the look of natural wood, it may not provide the same authentic appearance and feel as real hardwood. Discerning homeowners might notice the difference.
  • Lower Resale Value: LVP typically does not add as much resale value to a home as hardwood flooring. Potential buyers often view hardwood as a more premium feature.
  • Environmental Impact: LVP is made from synthetic materials, which can have a higher environmental impact compared to natural wood. Additionally, some LVP products may emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs).
  • Limited Refinishing Options: Unlike hardwood, LVP cannot be sanded and refinished. Once it shows signs of wear or damage, the affected planks need to be replaced.
  • Temperature Sensitivity: LVP can expand and contract with temperature changes, which might require careful installation and possibly the use of transition strips to manage this issue.
Close up view of luxury vinyl

Comparing Luxury Vinyl Planks and Hardwood for the Main Level

Choosing between hardwood and luxury vinyl planks (LVP) for your main level depends on your priorities. Hardwood offers timeless beauty and adds value but requires more maintenance. LVP is affordable, durable, and water-resistant, ideal for busy households. Consider your lifestyle and budget to make the best choice.

When deciding between luxury vinyl planks (LVP) and hardwood for your main level, it’s essential to consider several factors: aesthetics, durability, maintenance, cost, and overall value. Each flooring option offers unique benefits and potential drawbacks, influencing your decision based on your specific needs and preferences.

Aesthetics and Appearance

  • Hardwood: Provides a timeless, elegant look that is hard to replicate. The natural grain and rich tones of hardwood add warmth and sophistication to any space. It also ages beautifully, developing a patina that can enhance its character over time.
  • LVP: Modern LVP is designed to mimic the appearance of natural wood, often closely resembling hardwood floors. While it offers a wide range of styles and colors, some discerning homeowners might notice the difference in texture and authenticity compared to real wood.

Durability and Maintenance

  • Hardwood: Known for its durability, hardwood can last for decades with proper care. However, it requires regular maintenance, including sweeping, mopping, and occasional refinishing to address scratches and wear. Hardwood is also more susceptible to moisture and humidity, which can cause warping.
  • LVP: Highly durable and resistant to scratches, dents, and moisture. It requires minimal maintenance, typically only regular sweeping and mopping. LVP is less likely to be damaged by water, making it a more practical choice for busy households and areas prone to spills.
flooring maintenance

Cost and Value

  • Hardwood: Generally more expensive upfront, including higher installation costs. However, hardwood can add significant resale value to your home. 
  • LVP: More budget-friendly, with lower material and installation costs. While it may not add as much resale value as hardwood, LVP offers excellent value for money due to its durability and low maintenance requirements.

Comfort and Environmental Impact

  • Hardwood: Feels solid underfoot and adds a sense of permanence and quality. It is a natural, renewable resource, though responsible sourcing is important to minimize environmental impact. It is versatile and can be used in different housing types such as beach houses.
  • LVP: Softer and more comfortable underfoot compared to hardwood. Some options include cushioned backing for added comfort. However, LVP is made from synthetic materials and may have a higher environmental impact, including potential VOC emissions.
Flooring installation

Choosing Luxury Vinyl or Hardwood for the Main Level

Choosing between LVP and hardwood for your main level depends on your priorities. If you value timeless aesthetics, potential resale value, and a natural look, hardwood is an excellent choice. Its classic appeal and durability make it a worthwhile investment, especially in living rooms and dining areas where it can be showcased.

On the other hand, if practicality, budget, and ease of maintenance are your main concerns, LVP is a compelling option. Its water resistance and durability make it ideal for high-traffic areas and homes with children or pets. LVP can also be a great choice for kitchens and bathrooms, where moisture resistance is crucial.

Conclusion: Which is Best?

Both hardwood and luxury vinyl planks offer distinct advantages for main level flooring. Hardwood impresses with its timeless beauty, potential to increase home value, and durability. In contrast, LVP stands out for its affordability, ease of maintenance, and water resistance. Your choice should align with your lifestyle, budget, and aesthetic preferences to ensure you get the best flooring solution for your main level.

Looking for design experts? Talk to us!

Need a Remodeling Expert?

Contact us today for a free estimate and you will get all the details. Or call us: